S 269: Ending Improper Payments to Deceased People Act

S 269 in plain English: This law permanently allows the U.S. Treasury Department to access Social Security Administration death records to help prevent and recover improper payments made to deceased individuals. It also sets a higher evidence standard before the SSA can officially record someone as deceased, and creates a correction process for people wrongly marked as dead.

Stated purpose

This act aims to stop improper government payments to deceased individuals by permanently allowing the Treasury Department to access Social Security death records and by setting stricter standards before someone can be listed as deceased.

Key points

• Permanently allows Treasury to access SSA death records to stop payments to deceased individuals
• Makes permanent the requirement for SSA to share its Death Master File with Treasury's Do Not Pay system
• Requires SSA to have clear and convincing evidence before recording someone as deceased
• Allows people wrongly marked as deceased to submit documentation and have relevant agencies notified of the error
• Requires Treasury to share costs of state death data with SSA under a formal agreement

Arguments supporters make

• Taxpayer money should not go to people who have already died, and making data-sharing permanent closes a loophole that allowed improper payments to continue.
• Requiring 'clear and convincing evidence' before marking someone as deceased protects living people from being cut off from benefits they are owed.
• Permanently linking SSA death records to Treasury's payment system creates a more reliable, long-term safeguard rather than relying on temporary or expiring rules.

Arguments opponents make

• Government databases already have a history of errors, and even with a higher evidence standard, some living people — especially vulnerable or elderly individuals — could still be wrongly flagged as deceased and lose access to critical benefits.
• Permanently expanding federal data-sharing between agencies raises privacy concerns about how sensitive personal records are stored, accessed, and potentially misused.
• The cost-sharing agreement between SSA and Treasury for state death data is left to negotiation, leaving open questions about whether agencies will adequately fund and maintain the accuracy of the system.

Tradeoffs

Broader and permanent data-sharing between federal agencies can reduce wasteful payments, but it also increases the risk of errors and privacy exposure for individuals whose personal records are shared across more government systems. Stricter evidence requirements protect living people from being wrongly listed as deceased, but may slow the removal of truly deceased individuals from payment rolls.

Current status in Congress: Became law.

NewsClear — neutral news & congressional tracking · Bill of the Week