S 5529: DEFEND IP Act

S 5529 in plain English: The DEFEND IP Act would establish legal measures to protect intellectual property rights, targeting domain name resolution services with annual revenues above $100,000,000.

Stated purpose

The DEFEND IP Act aims to let copyright owners or their exclusive licensees petition a U.S. federal court to formally designate foreign websites as 'foreign digital piracy sites,' and then require certain internet service providers and domain name resolution services to block or redirect access to those sites.

Key points

• Applies to domain name resolution service providers with annual revenue exceeding $100,000,000
• Targets entities involved in intellectual property infringement online

Arguments supporters make

• Foreign piracy sites cause real financial harm to American creators and rights holders, and this bill gives them a practical legal remedy when those sites are beyond the reach of U.S. law enforcement.
• The bill targets only foreign sites that a court has determined are likely infringing copyright, providing judicial oversight as a safeguard against abuse.
• Protecting live event transmissions addresses a growing and time-sensitive form of piracy that existing copyright law was not designed to handle quickly enough.

Arguments opponents make

• Blocking entire foreign websites based on one court petition could suppress lawful content that shares a domain with infringing material, raising free speech and due process concerns.
• Determined users can easily bypass DNS and IP blocks using VPNs or other tools, so the law may burden internet infrastructure companies without meaningfully reducing piracy.
• Placing blocking obligations on private broadband and DNS providers without compensation sets a precedent for governments to use internet companies as censorship infrastructure.

Tradeoffs

Stronger enforcement tools for copyright holders come at the cost of potentially restricting open internet access for users and placing new compliance burdens on large internet infrastructure providers; the benefit of deterring foreign piracy must be weighed against the risk of over-broad blocking of legitimate content.

Current status in Congress: In committee.

NewsClear — neutral news & congressional tracking · Bill of the Week